The Individual Reviews

BLT Margarita Ratings™

We personally visit every location, order the house margarita exactly as served and rate it on our 25-point BLT Ratings™ system.

No substitutions. No upgrades. No special requests.

Margarita at Portuguese Tavern Steakhouse in Clifton, New Jersey
25/25 · Perfect

Portuguese Tavern Steakhouse

Clifton, NJ
Read the rating →
 Margarita at LongHorn Steakhouse in Flanders, New Jersey
23.5/25 · Port Worthy

LongHorn Steakhouse

Flanders, NJ
Read the rating →
 Margarita at Eddie's Roadhouse in Warwick, New York
23/25 · Port Worthy

Eddie's Roadhouse

Warwick, NY
Read the rating →
 Margarita at The Post Time Pub in Blairstown, New Jersey
23/25 · Port Worthy

The Post Time Pub

Blairstown, NJ
Read the rating →
 Margarita at The Red Dog Tavern in Morristown, New Jersey
22/25 · Port Worthy

The Red Dog Tavern

Morristown, NJ
Read the rating →
 Margarita at Inhouse in Blairstown, New Jersey
21/25 · Smooth Sailing

Inhouse

Blairstown, NJ
Read the rating →
 Margarita at Hyde-Away Restaurant and Tap Room in Stillwater, New Jersey
15/25 · Rough Seas

Hyde-Away Restaurant & Tap Room

Stillwater, NJ
Read the rating →
 Margarita at Brick and Brew in Franklin, New Jersey
7.5/25 · Walk the Plank

Brick & Brew

Franklin, NJ
Read the rating →
 Margarita at Irish Cottage Inn in Franklin, New Jersey
3/25 · Walk the Plank

Irish Cottage Inn

Franklin, NJ
Read the rating →
 Margarita at The Barge Restaurant and Cocktail in Perth Amboy, New Jersey
0/25 · Walk the Plank

The Barge Restaurant & Cocktail

Perth Amboy, NJ
Read the rating →
170 Margaritas and Counting

Find Your Next Great Margarita

Explore the Margarita Map Get the BLT Ratings™ Guide